Showing posts with label research. Show all posts
Showing posts with label research. Show all posts

Monday, October 8, 2012

Who was Joseph Newell?


So we're officially down the rabbit hole...

My first stop was the Vital Records of Brookfield, MA for some genealogical information. (Turns out that New Braintree was not incorporated until 1751) I found out that Joseph Newell was born on July 2, 1747 to Daniel & Miriam. He married Ruth Wright on September 14, 1780, had a pile of kids, and died on December 26, 1831 at the ripe old age of 84.

Now this all started with the question of the missing years in Joseph's account book.  Well, it appears that he did go off to war in 1778. According to the Massachusetts Soldiers and Sailors of the Revolutionary War, Volume 11 there is a listing for a Joseph Newell.
"Joseph Newell, Brookfield - Return of men raise to serve in the Continental Army from Captain Nathan Hamilton's (1st) co, Col Converse (4th Worcester Co.) regt., Sworn to at Brookfield Feb 18, 1778. Residence Brookfield; engaged for town of Brookfield (also given Western) Joined Capt Haywood's co., Col Nixon's regiment"
I guess we'll need to return to the account book to see if the 1779 entries were made in a different hand or if we misread the dates, which was entirely possible since the writing near the edges of the pages was very difficult to read.

It would appear that prior to the war, Joseph Newell was an active member of his community. In The History of North Brookfield by Josiah Howard Temple & Charles Adams published in 1887, there is a mention that, on March 14, 1774, Town Officers were elected, and Joseph Newell, along with "Benjamin Gilbert, Benjamin Lynde, Solo. Banister, John Barrows, Amos Adams" were appointed, "hog reeves".  Seems that hog reeve is a fancy title for those responsible for ensuring that the town's porcine residents remained in their pens. During that same year Gad Williston was elected as a "warden". Who is Gad Williston? Why one of Joseph's customers.......

Gad Williston 1768 December For mending close 0 1 0 0
For making your self a coat 0 8 0 0
For making Caleb a jacet 2/8 0 2 8 0
For mending yourself a pare of breeches 0 0 6 2
For mending a great coat for you 0 0 4 0
For making Caleb a coat and jacket 0 12 8 0
1770 27-Jul For making your self a pare of breeches 0 4 9 2

For mending a pare of breeches 0 1 0 0
For mending a coat and jacet 0 1 0 0
28-Jul For mending yourself a pair of breeches and for seting on butens in your great coat and *streat" 0 0 9 0
For making your self a cloak and ? 0 0 8 0
for two yards of camlet and a quarter 0 6 5 0
21-Jun ditto for making a jacket 0 9 0 0
2 9 5 0
11-Jun For making a pair of leather breaches and finding trimming for the same 0 8 0 0
To pare of a lambskin and making a pare of drawers and finding thread 0 4 0 0
To leather for a glove 0 3 7 0
To 8 pence in money but if overpaid in borrowed money  0 7 0 0
to making your boy a pair of breeches and finding leather 0 1 5 0

I wonder if the "Caleb" mentioned in these entries was a servant, as there is no listing for a son named Caleb born to Gad and his wife, Lucy. And is "your boy" a reference a slave or a son? Gad's first son was born in 1773, and unfortunately, we don't have a year noted for that entry.

Just for fun, I searched for both Joseph Newell and Gad Williston in the Historical Newspapers. It appears that Gad Williston had an apprentice that ran away.  Maybe he took the leather breeches that Joseph Newell made.  And was Gad Williston a hatter? (Appropriate that we might run into a hatter)



Now we know a little more about Joseph Newell -- That he went off to war at 31, married on his return and had children.  I'm sure there is more out there on him and will probably check in with Brookfield Historical to see if they have anything.  I suspect you see a pattern here. The more you discover, the more questions pop up, begging to be answered. So what if we do some checking on Mr. Newell's other customers?

Our next adventure down the rabbit hole gets really interesting, and leads to sex, murder, intrigue, a well-known Tory father-in-law, and a famous execution! Stay tuned.....




Friday, October 5, 2012

Research - The Rabbit Hole!

This morning, I was going to try to figure out how much Joseph Newell charged to make leather breeches versus how much the leather cost.  Unlike James Gould from Newport, who consistently charged the same amount, over and over again, for a pair of breeches, it is difficult to discern at first glance, when Mr. Newell included the materials because his prices are all over the map.  Then I started to look at the dates and noticed something....

His entries pretty much petered out by 1776 and resumed again around 1783.  There are a few entries in between, but it would appear that most of his customers and/or he went off to war.  There are a few entries from 1776-1783, but I didn't notice, for example, if these wartime entries were made in a different hand or then again, he might have only served a few years or we may have misread these entries, as the dates in the left hand columns were sometimes tough to make out.



So here's why doing research is like Alice in Wonderland's rabbit hole - it sucks you in, you don't know where it will take you but, oh, what interesting things you find out on the way! 

The primary exercise of seeking out account books was to explore another form of primary source in order to learn more about period clothing, what it cost and what it was made of, etc. And look at the can of worms this opened.  What about the missing years in Mr Newell's account books?  What if we explored Joseph Newell's genealogy - check out if there are any military records on him? We could go to the Massachusetts archives to see if there are any probate records connected to him.  Did he own property?  Maybe contact the New Braintree Historical Society. And what about his customers? What can we find out about them? Two words: MORE RESEARCH.

Oh no! I think I'm about to fall down the rabbit hole.






Tuesday, July 31, 2012

Documenting Your Duds

Today we're going to take a look at documenting a middlin' class impression.  Even though surviving artifacts and portraits are rare for this group of folks, there is still lots of material to pull from. English genre art is a good place to start, but be careful of using them too literally since frequently things are being lampooned and, a lot of the times, we're not getting the joke. For today's example, I have chosen one of my favorite prints from the Lewis Walpole collection, "A Ladies Maid Purchasing a Leek" 1772. 

It is important to know that documenting your clothing does not mean you need to be running out trying to draft originals from collections. As I mentioned yesterday, many scholars have already done this for you, I'll use some in our example today.  In addition, your documentation doesn't necessarily have to be a work of art either. Sure, it's nice to have your items photographed professionally and to show off your graphic design skills, but it's not required, all you need is the information in writing and your sources cited.

A Middlin' Woman Impression





Shift: linen as described in Costume Close-up by Linda Baumgarten 1999, Colonial Williamsburg Foundation

Stays: as described in Costume Close-up by Linda Baumgarten 1999, Colonial Williamsburg Foundation

Gown: Open front gown, blue worsted, tabby weave
PA Gazette 10-16-1766
Quilted Petticoat: MFA Accession# 28.528b Pink Silk

Quilted petticoat
My reproduction

 Black Silk Bonnet over linen cap (as pictured in print)

Linen apron and printed cotton handkerchief (as pictured in print)

My interpretation

Shoes: Black Leather Shoes from Burnley & Trowbridge
NH Gazette 12-26-1766

If this all seems overwhelming, start with documenting your outer garment first and work from there.  Once you do this a couple times, it gets easier. And by the way, when you are shopping on sutler row, don't be afraid to ask for their primary sources.  The best sutlers have done their homework and will be able to cite them for you.


Wednesday, October 5, 2011

What gown style is right for me?

In our area we reenact the period from 1770-1783.  Will one gown work for us?  Probably, but that question and answer requires some thought and some research.  Here's the thing, your clothing doesn't have to be the latest in fashion, by the same token, you shouldn't be wearing styles that haven't been invented yet.  (you can go back but not forward) And frankly, it's the latter that needs to be addressed as we take steps towards greater authenticity.

The basic rule of dressing for 18th century reenactors has essentially been -- stomacher front gown for French & Indian War and a center front closing gown for Rev War.  In our humble opinion we need to be a bit more specific than that and base our choices on documented research not reenactor tradition.  The busy bees at the Hive have been pondering this as of late and are trying to nail down a date when the front closing gown started to take hold.  Examination of  artwork would suggest somewhere around 1775-1778.

This first image by Anna Frankland Lewis is dated 1774.

LACMA

 This is her version of the "Dress of the Year" which would make it in the forefront of fashion in 1774.  It is still a gown with an open front, with probably gauze or lace trimmings and a vertical decoration running down either side of bodice center fronts. Make note of the fact that this still a fashion plate, not a real gown.

This next watercolor by Anna Frankland Lewis is the earliest representation of a closed front gown that we have yet found and it is dated 1775.


 This is Anna's interpretation of either a fashion plate or image from an almanac. You can clearly see the closed front bodice of this gown.  High fashion in 1775- in silk.


 This blown up version shows clearly the gown meeting in center front, with the same vertical trimming at center front as the earlier gown. The aesthetic has changed.  This is a pretty dramatic change for a gown style that has been in place for many decades.  It is daring, revolutionary and cutting edge. 

How long did it take for this fashion to reach down into everyday life of the ordinary woman?  Right now in 2011 it takes about a year after seeing something trendy in New York City to see the same fashion trend in small town Massachusetts and we have the internet!  and magazines! and TV!

Let's look at the questions this all brings up. 

Was there a transition style from one to the other?

Where does the so called zone gown fit into the equation?

How quickly does the front closing gown become the style of choice in the colonies - especially for the poor and middle class?

How did one learn how to make this new style? 

So what are you finding?  When are you seeing center front closing gowns appearing and when are they being worn by the masses (Colonial & English women)?   Your thoughts?
 
The buzzing bees

Tuesday, August 30, 2011

Focusing the Zoom Lens: 1770-1783

The Hive blog in the next few months is going to be taking an in depth look at the styles of gowns worn during the time period of 1770-1783 from both the standpoint of fashion and social context.

A common error made by many reenactors is dressing “generically" 18th century.  If a re-enactor is wearing something that was worn sometime between 1740-1790  it is working for them. Many will read this and say why bother, it is just a hobby.  Get over it.  Why do the guys bother discussing uniform buttons for days on end and the lock of a musket or the strap on a cartridge case?  If those details are important for them, shouldn't our details as women be important to us?

 Here in the New England area, Revolutionary War reenactors participate in events that range in date from 1770 to 1783, a span of thirteen years!   That 13 year time period saw not only the Tea Party and the American Revolution, but also a revolution of style in clothing, especially for women.  It is our intention to focus as best we can on those stylistic changes over that 13 year time period.

 Up until the explosion of the internet, providing us ALL with access to newspaper archives, portrait and print collections as well as the treasures locked away in museum storage, this information was available only to a small circle.  Colonial Williamsburg with its many archives and collections, always had this advantage and has shared much of their research with symposiums, books and exhibits.  Now it is up to all of us to start doing our own work, the information is there.  Shame on us if we don't even look at it!

We are going to take a methodical look at portraits, extant garments and the social media of the day, the satires, to build a case for change over time in women's clothing among the various social strata, and how we should or should not be reflecting those changes in our dress.

Each of those areas of research has issues: portraits in the colonies reflect the upper class of society, extant garments are often undated or misdated with no provenance and the satires have pointed jokes that we often don't understand.  

We will do our best to look at all the research available and hopefully we can draw our own conclusions when presented with the data.  We will strive for frank discussions based on facts not opinions.  Please join us in our quest!




Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Here We Are! Where are we going?

Old Sturbridge Village - 2009

At a recent event, I had a chat with someone who has been away from the hobby for a few years.  She noticed something remarkable about how the women were dressed at the recent BAR event in Needham, Massachusetts.  She noted how just a few years ago there was a real bell curve when it came to accuracy in women's clothing.  A few were really bad, most fell into some middle ground of generally acceptable, but not really great either, with only a few really outstanding impressions on the other end of the spectrum.  Her current observation was that most of the middle ground have joined the ranks of the good and she noticed a larger gap between poor impressions and ones that were really well done.

Hartwell Tavern 2010

What this seems to indicate is that we, as female reenactors, have made great strides in presenting ourselves as 18th Century women.  It is especially noticeable at events at Minute Man National Historical Park where standards have been in place for several years.

Foodways Preservation Program - Hartwell Tavern 2010

The majority of women are now in stays and gowns. There is a nice diversity and selection of fabrics, very few bad cotton prints, and for the most part, women in our New England area are reflecting the recent scholarship on how people in greater Boston were dressed in the 18th Century.   This has all happened in the last 5-6 years, and not by accident.  The Internet has made the dissemination of information easier, museums are putting their collections on line, specialized yahoo groups have emerged, new clothing patterns have become available, there are more quality sutlers out there, new books published, and a community of sharing at Minute Man NHP, through the Hive Programs, have all combined into a perfect storm for reenactors to create and wear more historically accurate clothing.

 Hartwell Tavern - 2009

So what's next, now that the basics are well in hand?

Though we’re looking much better overall, if we zoom in the lens of the time machine a little closer, it becomes evident that we should focus our efforts on paying closer attention to time, place, social status, and the details of our overall look.  Over the next several months, this blog will be looking at how we, as women in New England, can fine-tune our impressions.  We will do that by examining the documentation and hopefully opening up a dialog that will bring additional findings to light and start the process of bringing our 18th century impressions to the next level! 
 Shift Race - Hartwell Tavern MMNHP

Please feel free to comment and make suggestions, a dialogue takes more than one person!

 The Hive Collective

Monday, February 28, 2011

Sources for Sources

Thanks to the internet and searchable online archives, finding primary source material for research is a great deal easier than it was even a few years ago.

Some of the best archives with search capabilities:

Old Bailey Online

The Proceedings of the Old Bailey are the published transcripts from trials held at the Old Bailey from 1674-1913.  They are searchable by date, subject matter and keywords.

Boston Public Library

America's Historic Newspapers 1690-1922 are a database of published newspapers, for 18th century purposes they contain published newspapers from many of the 13 colonies and can be searched by date, location of publication, type of article and keywords.  Massachusetts residents are able to attain an online library card which enables full use of the archives.

Accessible Archives

For an annual membership these archives are keyword searchable with mainly18th century Pennsylvania newspapers and publications.

Lewis Walpole Library Digital Collection

A searchable collection by keyword or date, this is a treasure trove of 18th and 19th century British Prints.

Friday, February 25, 2011

Researching Cloaks and Everything Else

How did Sue Felshin find the documentation and resources used to write her article on short cloaks?

The first step is to recognize the various types of sources that provide information while studying historical costume.  They can easily be broken down into two main categories, primary and secondary.

Primary sources are original uninterpreted information.  For our purposes a newspaper advertisement, diary, inventory entry, ledger or artifact can be a primary source.


New Hampshire Gazette, June 29, 1774
This advertisement tell us that a black silk cloak with taffeta (smooth lightweight silk) on the outside and a persian lining (lightweight silk often used to line 18th century garments) is interlined with blue baize (a heavy woolen cloth) was lost in Newington, New Hampshire.

Reading a primary 18th century document can be a challenge.  Creative and inconsistent spelling and odd abbreviations are the norm.  Textile terminology can be often confusing and incomprehensible utilizing unfamiliar words in unusual ways, almost a new language and it is not English! 






A dictionary is invaluable when studying a new language, and the best textile dictionary currently available to us is Florence Montgomery's, "Textiles in America 1650-1870", ISBN-10: 039373224X.  Her comprehensive explanations combined with an easy alphabetical format makes looking up words such as "persian" a snap!

Secondary sources are written by those not directly involved with the primary event, such as analysis of and comments on primary sources.  Sue's article on short cloaks, uses primary sources for information, but her conclusions while based on those primary sources becomes a secondary source.